Blue Label CEO: Telkom sale will be good for Cell C
A Telkom South Africa merger with either MTN or Rain would be good news for mobile operator Cell C, according to Blue Label Telecoms' joint CEO, Brett Levy, whose company owns a 45% stake in Cell C.
Levy was answering questions from the media as part of the group's full year results for the 2022 financial year and called a possible buyout of Telkom "very interesting" and something that will shake up the SA market.
"From a Blue Label perspective, [it will be] much of a muchness, business as usual. From a Cell C perspective, I think it's very positive, either way it goes, because Cell C just becomes an important cog in the wheel for both MTN and Vodacom," he said pointing out that Cell C already has roaming agreements with both MTN and Vodacom.
In July, MTN and Telkom confirmed that they were discussing the possibility of MTN buying Telkom. Then in August data-only network, Rain threw its hat in the ring, by sending Telkom's board a request to meet over a proposed merger of the two companies.
"Blue Label wasn't for sale so they had to deal with each other" Levy joked about the possible tie-ups.
"It's interesting because a Rain-Telkom tie-up, they must have their reasons, and an MTN-Telkom tie-up, they must have their reasons. We obviously know one of the greatest assets is Openserve, it's obviously the fiber [footprint], that goes without saying," he added.
The market hasn't heard much more from MTN on the matter – besides that discussions were still ongoing – but Rain got a rap on the knuckles from SA's Takeover Regulation Panel which said Rain should have sought its approval before making the merger announcement.
Levy believes that whatever deal is made, time is of the essence.
"Telkom can't have a strategy of rolling out base stations if MTN is going to buy it. You can't have two base stations next to each other. So, if it's going to be an MTN-Telkom tie up, it's got to have quite a lot of action quickly. Because otherwise Telkom's going to waste a lot of money on things it won't use post the transaction."
"They all make sense but whatever happens it has to happen very quickly because the strategies to merge have to align right. So, as I said you can't have Telkom building the network and MTN building the network because whatever Telkom spends from this day onward, if they merge with MTN, that Telkom spend was an absolute waste of money. Just principally because they could roam on MTN and have the exact same coverage," Levy explained.
He said that whatever deal ends up being made he doesn't think the entity sold will be Telkom as we know it today, he thinks it will likely be sold in pieces and not as a whole.
On Thursday, Blue Label reported a year-on-year gross profit increase of 23%, to 2.93 billion South African rand (US$174 million) for the 12-months ended May 31, 2022.
A big chunk of Blue Label's business is selling prepaid airtime for all of the operators so an MTN-Telkom merger would be unlikely to impact its business as the sales will just continue for the combined entity.
Telkom overtook Cell C as SA's third biggest mobile operator in early 2020 when its subscribers topped 12 million for the first time and Cell C's fell to 11 million.
By June 2022 Telkom's mobile customers had grown to over 17.3 million, while Cell C's were around 13.3 million, according to statistics from market research company Omdia. Vodacom is still the market leader in SA with over 51.8 million users and MTN has over 35.3 million.
Rain is privately owned and doesn't often divulge subscriber numbers but is estimated to have under 1 million users on its network. It is also not a traditional operator like its peers as it only offers 4G and 5G data services.
Cell C has also struggled with financial challenges over the years and is in the midst of a recapitalization deal which Levy said should be finalized by mid-September 2022.
In August 2017 Blue Label bought a 45% stake in Cell C for R5.5 billion ($328 million) but by the end of 2019, it had to write down the value of its entire investment in Cell C to zero.
- Breaking: MTN wants to buy Telkom SA
- Buyout offers Rain down on Telkom SA
- Profit grows for SA's Blue Label Telecoms as it eyes nano-loans market
*Top image is of Blue Label Telecoms' joint-CEO Brett Levy. (Source: Blue Label Telecoms).
— Paula Gilbert, Editor, Connecting Africa